Adversives are Illegal Elsewhere. Why not here?

Episode 43: Mar 14, 2023 Warning: Sensitive Content

Why are shock collars still legal in the US? What progress have we made to change this?

The following information is from The Dog Central.

What is the Negative Impact of Shock Collars? The use of shock is damaging. It affects the physical and mental health of dogs. Multiple and excessive shocks can breach the skin of the dog. This leads to severe burns on the dog’s skin. Also, the skin becomes wounded and causes bleeding several times.

• Sometimes the electric shock collars are worn so tightly; the dog cannot breathe properly. This may lead to suffocation. In extreme cases, the dog may die.

• Frequent shocks can affect the normal functioning of cardiac muscles. This imposes a considerable strain on the heart. This strain gives rise to pressure in blood vessels. Also, the imposed stress on the heart plays with the normal flow of blood circulating in the body.

• The stress on the heart possibly affects the respiration rate of the dog. As a result, the dog feels uncomfortable while breathing. This malfunctioning of the respiratory tract generates problems in the gastrointestinal tract. With the issues in the gastrointestinal tract, the digestion process of food in dogs is affected to a shocking level.

• Other than these physical injuries and problems, multiple shocks through shock collars bring aggression to the behavior of dogs. Some dogs might feel fear to do anything. This fear decreases the confidence level of dogs.

• Also, the dog feels depression and stress. These depression and stress make the pet dog show unfriendly behavior towards the owner.

Both the shock collars and prong collars lie in the category of training collars. Both are used to modify dogs’ behavior and repress some unwanted moods in them. In case to stop the dog from barking, any of these collars can be used. But there is a difference between the structure and functioning of both collars. Let’s separately see the difference between both anti-bark collars.

• Shock collars are electronic and produce electric shock. The dog senses this electric shock as a little tinkling effect. The dog owner or dog trainer holds the transmitter in his hands and presses the button on seeing any undesired behavior shown by the dog.

• Whereas prong collars are not electronic. These collars have metal chains linked with one another. At each link, there are nails with a pointed end. These pointed links or nails are faced towards the dog’s neck.

These training collars are used to train the dogs by negative reinforcement. When the owner or trainer sees the dog showing some unexpected bad behavior, they inflict the dog with shock by electric shock collars or by pulling the prong collar, so nails hit the dog’s skin.

Do Electronic Collars Harm the Dogs? Electronic shock collars, if used unchecked, lead to severe dog injuries. In addition, the dog can become more aggressive and unfriendly in behavior if his behavior is negatively reinforced. Electric shock dog collars generate shock to the dog’s skin. If the dog trainer increases the intensity and frequency of shocks, these shocks may rupture the dog’s skin and increase physical pain. Also, the overuse of electric shock collars lowers the normal functioning of a dog’s nervous system. Sudden shocks are welcoming to stress and depression for dogs.

Are Shock Collars Illegal?

According to many animal welfare organizations, the use of shock collars and any collar to punish dogs is illegal.

Punishing any animal against his natural behavior is wrong. Unfortunately, many trainers and pet owners punish their pets for very small and minor doings. They use e collars as training collars and give the pets severe shocks.

Instead of teaching good dogs behavior, these punishments show counter results. For example, the dogs become more aggressive, depressed, fearful, and weak.

Where Are Shock Collars Illegal? Many states of the world have made shock collars and e collars illegal. In addition, the countries such as Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Austria, and Canada have implemented a law that does not allow shock collar training.

What Countries Have Banned Shock Collars? Excess of everything leads to destruction. In the same way, the excessive usage of vibration collars, including shock collars, causes severe physical pain to the dogs. Not only this, but the recurrent use of vibration collars and electric shock collars causes physical and psychological harm to the dog. In this respect, many countries, including Norway, Sweden, Austria, Switzerland, Slovenia, and Canada, banned dog shock collars. The animal welfare act demands the government ban electric shock collars. Many countries such as Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Austria, Switzerland, Slovenia, Germany, and Canada have done this and illegalized remote-controlled collars in their states.

Are Shock Collars Banned in Australia? Shock collars have been banned in many states of Australia after considering the damaging effects of these e collars on dogs. In addition, the government of Australia illegalized shock collars that give a painful shock to the dogs, which is against dog welfare.

Are Shock Collars Banned in Canada? The government of Canada emphasized animal welfare and banned shock collars. According to the Canadian veterinary medical association, shock collars inflict pain on dogs. They also stated that dogs should be trained by positive reinforcement methods instead of negative reinforcement methods.

Are Shock Collars Banned in Europe? Europe has strictly banned e collars, spray collars, or any shock collars. The anti-bark collars appeared to be appealing to dogs’ more fearful or aggressive behavior. The local animal welfare organizations in Europe and animal activists have been working to make the community aware of the harms of shock collars during obedience training of dogs

What Are the Alternatives to Electronic Training Collars? Shock collars cause harm to the dogs. It is observed through studies that dogs or any other pet learn more when appreciated for good behavior other than punishing them over bad behavior. There are so many methods used for training the dogs instead of using shock collars for training. Let’s discuss these methods one by one.

Behavioral Training is long-term beneficial learning for the dogs. This training teaches the dog lessons about sitting, standing, carrying a thing, coming, lying down, or standing. These pieces of training are actual reward-based pieces of training. Reward-based training details strengthen the dog’s learning capability and provoke him to adopt positive behaviors for his whole life. Behavioral pieces of training are better than training the dogs by using a shock collar.

Whistles are extensively used for dog pieces of training. This is because the listening power of dogs is much higher than that of humans. Dogs can learn and adapt to so many sounds efficiently; for this reason, trainers mare the dogs to get used to whistles. Trainers use these whistles to appreciate the dogs for completing the command or to grab the dog’s attention. Dogs quickly learn this behavior and respond to the situation efficiently and accordingly.

Conclusion A dog can remain healthy if not punished for natural behaviors. Learning and training dogs is a good thing. But the use of electric shocks on dogs is bad and against the animal welfare act. These training collars can damage the physical and mental health of the pet dogs. When the shocks are given more than enough, these pose stress on dogs’ cardiac and nervous tissues. Ultimately the dogs become susceptible to depression, stress, and illness. Many countries, after throwing light on this issue, reached a solution. This solution was to illegalize all the electric and prong collars used in pet dog training. These countries have implemented the animal welfare act and have banned the use of these collars strictly. These countries include Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and Austria.